FORTUNE -- No question, workplace efforts to encourage people to take better care of themselves have caught on in recent years. Since about 60% of U.S. companies now offer some kind of wellness initiative, up from just 36% in 2009, designing and running such programs has grown into a $6-billion-a-year industry, according to a new study from nonprofit think tank Rand Corp.
What's more, because they're supposed to lower -- or at least contain -- the cost of medical care, the Affordable Care Act includes provisions that encourage their growth.
But do wellness programs really save money? A much-ballyhooed 2010 study by a Harvard economist says they do, to the tune of $3 in health care cost savings, and another $3 in reduced expenses from absenteeism, for each dollar companies spend on helping employees stay healthy.
Now, however, comes a somewhat different take, based on a six-year study of more than 67,000 PepsiCo (PEP) employees. Typical of most big companies' efforts, PepsiCo's program has several parts, including health-risk assessments, fitness-and-diet programs, and helping people manage chronic illnesses like diabetes and heart disease (which together make up about two-thirds of total U.S. medical spending).
That's important, because Rand's research found that returns vary markedly depending on which part of the program you look at. Consider: In line with earlier research, the latest analysis found that helping employees manage chronic illnesses saved $3.78 in medical costs for every dollar invested in the effort. Mostly because it cut the number and length of hospital stays, disease management accounted for about 87% of PepsiCo's total cost savings, even though only about 13% of employees participated.
By contrast, among the far larger number of employees who are healthy now and are trying to stay that way through diet and exercise, "the lifestyle-management component of the program -- while delivering benefits -- did not provide more savings than it cost to offer," said Soeren Mattke, the Rand senior scientist who led the study.
"While workplace wellness programs have the potential to reduce health risks and cut health care spending in the long run, employers and policymakers shouldn't take for granted that the lifestyle-management components of the programs can reduce costs or lead to savings overall," Mattke added.
Companies "need to be clear about their goals for the wellness program," the study concludes. "... [I]f an employer wants to improve employee health or productivity, an evidence-based lifestyle management program can achieve this goal," while also boosting workplace morale, other studies have shown. "But employers who are seeking a healthy ROI on their programs should target employees who already have chronic diseases."
In a candid conversation at Davos with Fortune managing editor Andy Serwer, PepsiCo CEO Indra Nooyi shares a few truly surprising management secrets.
FORTUNE -- Indra Nooyi has been CEO of PepsiCo since 2006 and during her tenure has seen a remarkable amount of change: from a financial meltdown to recovery, huge new scrutiny for her company's products, and a revolution in consumer technology. She also faced criticism over how she was running MOREJan 28, 2014 7:00 AM ET
Giants like Pepsi and Coke are going abroad to make money. What happens to old North American-based Dr Pepper?Shelley DuBois, writer-reporter - May 8, 2013 1:52 PM ET
Pepsico and Coke reported first-quarter earnings this week, and soda sales in the U.S. have flat-lined. But we're still hooked on the sugary stuff.Shelley DuBois, writer-reporter - Apr 19, 2013 5:00 AM ET
By the numbers, PepsiCo has done a pretty good job since she took the helm six years ago. So why is the CEO taking so much heat from investors?
By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large
FORTUNE -- "Now tell me again -- what exactly is the issue with this company?" Indra Nooyi asks with an edge to her voice.
She has just rattled off a list of statistics describing the financial performance of MOREMay 29, 2012 5:00 AM ET
It takes the right blend of good ideas and good leadership to make the CEO of General Electric's own list of Most Admired Companies.
FORTUNE -- We asked three prominent business leaders -- Jeffrey Immelt, Ursula Burns, and John Donahoe -- which companies they hold in high esteem, and why. Immelt, CEO of General Electric, (No. 15 on our list of Most Admired Companies) talked with reporter Daniel Roberts and listed a veritable Who's Who of companies MOREMar 1, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Some successful companies thrive on internal competition, giving many a manager the brilliant idea that they should try it at their own office. Think again. By Shelley DuBoisShelley DuBois, writer-reporter - Jan 25, 2012 12:45 PM ET
PepsiCo CEO Indra Nooyi sounded as much like one of the NGOs that have protested against some of the food giant's past decisions as she did its chief executive at Fortune's Most Powerful Women summit. By Jennifer ReingoldOct 5, 2011 1:23 PM ET
Boardroom battles and power plays shaped this year's U.S. list, which boasts eight new faces and - surprise! - a new No. 1.
By Beth Kowitt & Rupali Arora
There's been plenty of turmoil atop Fortune's annual Most Powerful Women list. Meg Whitman crashed the party, coming in at No. 9 when she became CEO of Hewlett-Packard (HPQ). (As CEO of eBay (EBAY), she was on the list from 1999 to 2007.) Longtime MPW Carol Bartz lost her job MORESep 29, 2011 7:00 AM ET
Storytelling in business can just as easily save the day as it can make a sticky situation even stickier. Here are a few lessons learned from people who have turned to stories in their work.
By Vickie Elmer, contributor
Ed Fuller tells of a dinner he had with eight Japanese bankers in the 1990s.
"I am the only Gaijin at the table, meaning white devil," he said with a small laugh. MOREDec 3, 2010 12:28 PM ET
|Delinquent IRS employees paid bonuses by the agency|
|Court quizzes Aereo: Do TV streams break the law?|
|Premarkets: Waiting for big tech earnings|
|Gun silencer sales are booming|
|How women can narrow the 'confidence gap'|