FORTUNE -- To some, Karl Rove is the heart and soul of the GOP. He has a long history of counseling prominent Republicans. Most memorably, he designed George W. Bush's successful presidential campaigns in 2000 and 2004. Recently, he co-founded and helped run the super PAC American Crossroads, which, along with affiliated groups, raised over $100 million for Governor Mitt Romney's presidential campaign.
Rove is also a public figure. He writes a column for the Wall Street Journal, and was frequently on Fox News during the 2012 election. On election night, Rove famously told the network to be cautious about calling swing state Ohio for Obama too soon, which spurred the network to interview its own decision desk on air.
Rove spoke with Fortune about why leading a super PAC is easier than building a political campaign and how he can't do anything about being a myth.
An edited transcript is below.
Fortune: Leading as an advisor is more behind the scenes than other kinds of leadership. What is it like to influence these incredibly powerful people?
Karl Rove: Well, I'm not certain I would necessarily agree with the term "incredibly powerful people." I do think that whenever you give advice to political clients, political candidates, or business organizations, you have to understand how they go about making decisions and what's their ultimate goal. And then there just has to be an incredible amount of directness.
Really? That's interesting. Because there's a general view that politicians dance around issues.
Well, you know, people are capable of keeping conflicting emotions and conflicting opinions of things in their brains at the same time. So a political candidate or an office holder needs to understand the best policy and then what's the best way to explain that policy. But sometimes, even doing the right thing will not be well received.
In retrospect, the surge in Iraq was the right decision for George W. Bush, but it was an unpopular decision at the time and it remains unpopular today.
Do you think it was unpopular because it wasn't communicated correctly?
No, look, sometimes people just don't have a good opinion about a particular policy. Now, ultimately they might look back and say, "That was the right thing to do," but particularly controversial measures tend to be controversial for a reason.
You've worked with many different politicians over time. How do you reconcile the needs of one candidate with the needs of the entire party?
Each political party is an expression of a large group of individual actors writing their own scripts. Generally, because our parties are, roughly, one center-left and the other center-right, the scripts tend to be similar.
Effective campaigns take the candidate at his or her natural best and put it on display, they don't mold a candidate into the ideal image of what the consultant thinks the people want to hear.
Voters, at the end of the day, are trying to do the right thing. Authenticity matters a lot.
This last election was exhausting. Do you still like what you do?
I enjoy the idea of a puzzle. And the puzzle is, "how do you take someone from where they are and get hem to the end?" It's also interesting because it's a collaborative process.
How is leading a super PAC different from organizing a campaign?
Decision-making tends to be easier. Campaigns are the expression of their candidates. So you'll have friends and advisors and spouses and a candidate who's on a campaign trail and needs time to absorb the information you're proposing.
It's just a lot less complicated and, as a result, a little bit more seductive in a super PAC world.
What about you? There is a kind of mythology around your power.
There is. I'm a myth, not a human being.
Why is that?
I have no idea. I think it's just easier. Political scientists use the term heuristics. Heuristics are shortcuts to understanding something broader about somebody or something.
Does that ever work to your advantage?
You know what? It is what it is. There's little or nothing I can do to change it.
I have to ask about the Fox broadcast of the election results. That was reported as a blow to your career, do you see it that way?
The Fox people thought it was good TV. They wanted an opportunity to explain how they arrive at a decision. They're sitting there saying, "We've now called Ohio and there's 991 votes separating the two candidates." So they wisely said, "We have confidence in our decision desk, but let's get Karl to voice this concern. It's a legitimate concern -- let's voice it and let's use this as a teachable moment."
Home furnishings CEO Judy George talks with Fortune about life as a working mom, cultivating a superhuman drive to succeed, and overcoming even the most public of failures.
Interview by Anne VanderMey
FORTUNE -- In 2008, it looked like it was the end of the road for Judy George. The company she started, furniture store Domain Home, had succumbed to the financial crisis. Though George was still the CEO, the company's new private MORENov 9, 2012 10:17 AM ET
The presidential candidates ran campaigns that were, in many ways, fueled by divisive politics. Now that it is over, how do we recover?
FORTUNE -- It's over, thank goodness, the election is over. Americans all over the ideological map can, at least, celebrate together that the attack ads, snarky debates, and divisive narratives of this presidential race have come to an end.
The ability to agree on that, or anything, may be MOREShelley DuBois, writer-reporter - Nov 8, 2012 1:27 PM ET
The candidates have offered starkly differently visions for the nation's future. Here's how some entrepreneurs are preparing.
By Elaine Pofeldt
FORTUNE – No matter who wins the election, Ted Devine isn't planning any radical moves for his business.
Devine, who is CEO of Insureon, an online commercial insurance agent based in Dallas, Texas that targets businesses with 10 employees or less, says the election will bring more certainty to the business community, MORENov 2, 2012 10:45 AM ET
In many ways, Mitt Romney was the quintessential Harvard Business School student, and alum. So why are the current crop of Harvard MBA candidates siding with his opponent? By John A. ByrneSep 21, 2012 9:09 AM ET
Despite claims from the Romney campaign that the candidate's energy plan will create 3 million jobs, the supporting evidence doesn't add up.
By Deena Shanker
FORTUNE -- With this election's sharp focus on jobs and the economy, both candidates are trying to show they can marry the goals of energy independence with employment and national economic growth.
Governor Mitt Romney says he will create more than 3 million jobs by easing restrictions MORESep 20, 2012 8:52 AM ET
The culture of stagnation in Congress is creeping into the business world. What will it take to get unstuck as America moves towards the fiscal cliff?
FORTUNE -- Most good decision-making practices grind to a halt during an election year.
President Barack Obama and former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney are both taking to the podium, talking up job creation and business recovery. Yet in the short term, government leaders are keeping employees MOREShelley DuBois, writer-reporter - Aug 23, 2012 11:58 AM ET
Here are five crucial leadership skills for the most powerful CEO of all -- the U.S. President.
By John Ryan
FORTUNE -- With the U.S. presidential election fast approaching, we will hear a lot from pundits and partisans over the next few months, not to mention President Obama and Gov. Mitt Romney themselves, about how one candidate's leadership skills are superior to his opponent's.
You can take their word for it -- MOREAug 14, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Every leader benefits enormously from having a wingman, a partner who can be counted on to counsel, goad, provoke, listen, and on and on. So, Mitt Romney, don't blow the VP thing. By Jack and Suzy WelchJul 5, 2012 10:43 AM ET
Taking charge, creating jobs, handling tough decisions - that's exactly what we need in our leaders, Mr. Vice President.
By Jack and Suzy Welch, contributors
FORTUNE -- Private equity executives and plumbers. In an obvious shot at Republican presidential candidate and Bain Capital chief Mitt Romney, Vice President Joe Biden said a few weeks back that they're equally prepared to be President -- which is to say not at all. With MOREJun 18, 2012 5:00 AM ET
|McDonald's gives Charles Ramsey free food for a year|
|Where your donation dollars go|
|The 'chicken poop' credit and other bad tax breaks|
|Why doesn't Apple cut its prices and sell more iPhones?|
|Make $30 an hour, no bachelor's degree required|