FORTUNE -- No question, workplace efforts to encourage people to take better care of themselves have caught on in recent years. Since about 60% of U.S. companies now offer some kind of wellness initiative, up from just 36% in 2009, designing and running such programs has grown into a $6-billion-a-year industry, according to a new study from nonprofit think tank Rand Corp.
What's more, because they're supposed to lower -- or at least contain -- the cost of medical care, the Affordable Care Act includes provisions that encourage their growth.
But do wellness programs really save money? A much-ballyhooed 2010 study by a Harvard economist says they do, to the tune of $3 in health care cost savings, and another $3 in reduced expenses from absenteeism, for each dollar companies spend on helping employees stay healthy.
Now, however, comes a somewhat different take, based on a six-year study of more than 67,000 PepsiCo (PEP) employees. Typical of most big companies' efforts, PepsiCo's program has several parts, including health-risk assessments, fitness-and-diet programs, and helping people manage chronic illnesses like diabetes and heart disease (which together make up about two-thirds of total U.S. medical spending).
That's important, because Rand's research found that returns vary markedly depending on which part of the program you look at. Consider: In line with earlier research, the latest analysis found that helping employees manage chronic illnesses saved $3.78 in medical costs for every dollar invested in the effort. Mostly because it cut the number and length of hospital stays, disease management accounted for about 87% of PepsiCo's total cost savings, even though only about 13% of employees participated.
By contrast, among the far larger number of employees who are healthy now and are trying to stay that way through diet and exercise, "the lifestyle-management component of the program -- while delivering benefits -- did not provide more savings than it cost to offer," said Soeren Mattke, the Rand senior scientist who led the study.
"While workplace wellness programs have the potential to reduce health risks and cut health care spending in the long run, employers and policymakers shouldn't take for granted that the lifestyle-management components of the programs can reduce costs or lead to savings overall," Mattke added.
Companies "need to be clear about their goals for the wellness program," the study concludes. "... [I]f an employer wants to improve employee health or productivity, an evidence-based lifestyle management program can achieve this goal," while also boosting workplace morale, other studies have shown. "But employers who are seeking a healthy ROI on their programs should target employees who already have chronic diseases."
Obama's above-the-fray leadership style has been effective in holding Democrats together, but it's failed -- at least, so far -- to bring Republicans to the negotiating table.Claire Zillman, reporter - Oct 2, 2013 5:00 AM ET
Major U.S. corporations like IBM and Walgreen are sending retirees and current employees to health exchanges, a sign of major changes to American health care.Sep 20, 2013 9:44 AM ET
Despite an October 1 deadline for getting the word out, 70% of workers say their employers haven't yet told them how their benefits could change.Anne Fisher, contributor - Sep 18, 2013 1:51 PM ET
All is not lost. Instead of opting for the penalty and sending your employees to the health exchanges, there are several ways to reduce health costs and treat your staffers decently.Jul 9, 2013 10:37 AM ET
When it comes to obesity -- a stubborn condition that the sharpest medical minds can't reliably treat -- is it fair to penalize an employee for staying heavy?Apr 15, 2013 12:10 PM ET
Legions of small and midsize businesses that don't offer health insurance have to quickly come up with a game plan. Here's what some are thinking.
By Elaine Pofeldt
FORTUNE -- Lenny Verkhoglaz wishes he could provide health insurance to the nearly 300 home care aides he employs at Executive Care, based in Hackensack, N.J. No such luck.
Verkhoglaz hasn't been able to muster enough participation among his employees to qualify for the MOREJan 14, 2013 10:54 AM ET
Let's focus on passing laws that will make constituents healthy. You will save lives.
By David Agus, contributor
FORTUNE -- In 2008, in New York City, a rule went into effect that restricted all food services from using more than half a gram of trans fat per serving. Similar restrictions have since been adopted by at least 15 other local and state jurisdictions in the U.S. For every additional 2% of MOREOct 17, 2012 5:00 AM ET
A management shakeup won't stop EVP Lori Beer from yanking the insurer into the digital era.
By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large
FORTUNE -- No company insures the health of more Americans -- or faces higher stakes in health care reform -- than WellPoint (WLP). Operating mostly under the Blue Cross and Blue Shield brands, it covers 34 million members, plus some dependents, totaling about 70 million people. Wall Street has generally MORESep 13, 2012 5:00 AM ET
Steward Health Care System's Ralph de la Torre is building a model for the future.
By Geoff Colvin, senior editor-at-large
FORTUNE -- What's the future of American health care? Dr. Ralph de la Torre, CEO of Steward Health Care System, may represent the answer. Steward, owned by the private equity firm Cerberus Capital Management, is a growing Massachusetts-based group of community hospitals, and industry analysts say de la Torre is one MOREAug 2, 2012 5:00 AM ET
|AT&T cuts prices again|
|The medical marijuana ad that never aired, despite contrary media headlines|
|Get ready for 'over-the-top' TV|
|China to fight pollution with drones|
|The bull market at 5: Not old yet|