best practices

Why your company (probably) can't innovate

October 6, 2011: 2:28 PM ET

Most of the conventional wisdom about how to generate world-beating business ideas is wrong, says a new book. Which practices belong on the scrap heap?

By Anne Fisher, contributor

FORTUNE -- The trouble starts with who gets hired.

In most companies, an essential criterion is "fit" — that is, how well a candidate would blend in with the existing culture. Then, top management asks everyone for ideas, sometimes even setting up contests to crown winners. And of course, the best way to spur people on to greater achievement is to give them plenty of pats on the back for a job well done.


Well, actually, no. According to Stephen Shapiro, you should be recruiting iconoclasts who don't fit the existing mold, including "people you don't like," because innovation depends on divergent points of view. Asking for ideas is fine if done correctly (hint: it helps to ask the right questions), but too often what companies get is a welter of impractical suggestions that just clutter up the system.

And by the way, stop congratulating employees for doing their jobs. "When you recognize people for doing what they were hired to do, it reinforces a culture where the status quo is good enough," Shapiro says -- the kiss of death for any enterprise trying to stay ahead of the game.

Shapiro, who has advised clients like Staples (SPLS), General Electric (GE), and the U.S. Air Force on how to innovate, has now distilled his methods into a book called Best Practices Are Stupid: 40 Ways to Out-Innovate the Competition. Refreshingly free of consultantese, it's loaded with succinct, down-to-earth case studies.

You might wonder, for instance, what's wrong with running contests that offer a prize for the best employee suggestion. After all, it's been done by Cisco (CSCO), LG Electronics, and GE. But, if you've already decided in advance that there is going to be a winner, you risk ending up with a "best" idea that is impressive in theory but falls short of solving a real, pressing problem. More

Current Issue
  • Give the gift of Fortune
  • Get the Fortune app
  • Subscribe
Powered by VIP.