FORTUNE -- Abercrombie & Fitch CEO Mike Jeffries opened his earnings conference call on Wednesday with mention of the "challenging retail environment, particularly in the teen space."
The retailer's fourth quarter performance certainly reflects that sentiment. Though it beat analyst estimates and its stock is up, the retailer's profits shrank by 58% to $66.1 million from $157.2 million during the same quarter the previous year. Net sales fell 12% to $1.3 billion, and same-store sales shrank 8%.
The poor earnings are just the latest chapter in Abercrombie's (ANF) long tumble from its 1990s-era halcyon days, when teens shopped in real, live stores and wanted to cover themselves with suggestive graphics and moose logos.
There's one major factor to blame for Abercrombie's slide, and it's the same culprit that's causing an upheaval in retail everywhere. No drum roll needed, it's the Internet.
It used to be that fashion trends would start out in Europe, make their way to America's coasts, and then infiltrate the Midwest over the course of several years. "Now a kid in Ames, Iowa can buy the same product at the same time as a kid who lives in Astor Place in New York," says Eric Beder, managing director at Brean Capital.
Trends crop up -- and flame out -- faster. Traditional stores, which can take up to six months to produce new products, have a hard time responding. In the teen space, where trends evolve even more quickly, retailers like Abercrombie have been caught flat-flooted.
Into this space have stepped so-called fast fashion retailers like Zara, H&M, and Forever 21, whose products are cheaper and less durable and therefore faster to produce, says David McGoldrick, a U.S. analyst for Euromonitor International. Abercrombie has always used its clothing's quality as a selling point, but that doesn't woo customers the way it used to. Who needs a sweater that will last 10 years when you're just going to buy a new one three months later? Jeffries acknowledged these shortcomings on Wednesday, saying the company would work on decreasing its lead times and planned to "reengineer" some of its products.
"We're not seeing pricing power for retailers. It used to be that if it was the right product, price was irrelevant," says Beder. "That's no longer the case."
Teens' recent penchant for bargain hunting is also working against Abercrombie. A Piper Jaffray biannual survey in October 2013 showed that teen spending on fashion had declined compared to the previous year, and that shopping trips were down nearly 25%. Teens are trying to get the most out of the money that they do spend: Approximately 71% of teen girls and 57% of teen boys shop at off-price stores (think T.J. Maxx or Marshall's) and 52% and 45%, respectively, indicated it is popular to do so.
A social shift is also at play. The recent recession seems to have made teens more socially conscious. Researchers at San Diego State University and University of California, Los Angeles found that high school seniors' concern for others declined significantly between the mid-1970s and the mid-2000s, and then climbed during the 2008-2010 recession. Teens are turning down the heat at home to help the environment, they're more willing to use bikes or mass transit instead of cars, and -- to Abercrombie's dismay -- they're no longer interested in advertising their brand allegiance or wearing t-shirts that proclaim "More boyfriends than T.S." (T.S. stands for singer Taylor Swift, obviously.)
"Teens are not as logo-driven," says Beder. "They don't want to be billboards for companies any more." Just look at the success of Urban Outfitters, whose hipster, logoless duds are a hit with the 18-and-under crowd. "This is a social change. These things come in five- or six-year cycles. In better economic times, teens may want to show off logos again, but as of right now, teen [retail] players have to adjust."
In October, founder Sara Blakely told Fortune her ultimate dream is to create the world's most comfortable high heel. The hosiery company's interim CEO Gregg Ribatt happens to be a shoe industry expert.
By Colleen Leahey, reporter
FORTUNE -- Smoothing tums and bums since its founding in 2000, shapewear retailer Spanx has solved countless women's maddening fashion problems. Its core products help the lumpiest of stomachs fit smoothly beneath form-fitting ensembles -- MOREFeb 12, 2014 10:06 AM ET
With a wild-card founder and complex offerings, the company struggles to win over the crop of haters that arose after last spring's product recall.
FORTUNE -- Thursday, Lululemon founder and chairman Chip Wilson blamed his company's customers for the retailer's product issues. "Quite frankly some women's bodies just actually don't work for it," he said on Bloomberg TV, referring to sheerness and pilling in Lululemon's famed yoga pants.
Lululemon (LULU) survived the springtime recall MOREColleen Leahey, Reporter - Nov 8, 2013 4:46 PM ET
Burch says the former Wal-Mart President and CEO "adds a lot of spice."
By Erika Fry, reporterFORTUNE -- Tory Burch, valued at more than $3 billion and known for its wildly popular ballet flats and print tunics, has also been adding some flair to its board of late.
The company recently added Lee Scott, the former President and CEO of Wal-Mart (WMT), to its board, CEO Tory Burch told Fortune Thursday morning at the MOREOct 17, 2013 12:24 PM ET
How the designer who spun a vision of iconic Americana into a variety of labels is now taking his fashion empire overseas.
By Anne VanderMey, reporter
FORTUNE -- There are some classics that never go out of style -- Ralph Lauren (RL) has the earnings to prove it. The $6.9 billion that it made in fiscal 2012 outstrips by $1 billion what competitors such as PVH Corp. (PVH) (which owns Tommy MOREOct 24, 2012 5:00 AM ET
The former NBA star hopes to enter fashion's (really) big leagues.
By Daniel Roberts, reporter
FORTUNE -- What do most professional basketball players do after retiring? "A lot of guys get on the golf course," says Kevin Willis, whose 23 years in the NBA included a 2003 championship with the San Antonio Spurs. "A lot try to get into some type of business venture, but when you don't really have the experience, or MOREOct 31, 2011 5:00 AM ET
How Kevin Plank took Under Armour from wishful thinking to a $1 billion business and where the Baltimore brand is headed next.
By Daniel Roberts, reporter
FORTUNE -- "Boy, there's a lot of talk out there," Kevin Plank says into a microphone. He's alone on a stage looking out at 1,000 employees standing on a basketball court at Under Armour's Baltimore headquarters on Sept. 15. They've assembled for one of the company's MOREOct 26, 2011 5:00 AM ET
The CEO has already beat the odds with Under Armour. Now he's betting big on horse racing.
By Daniel Roberts, reporter
FORTUNE -- Kevin Plank, the former U Maryland football player who founded Under Armour (UA), has not been all that showy with his money. In 2009, Plank gave himself an honorable pay cut, dropping his salary from $500,000 to $26,000. (Of course, with 22% ownership of the company's stock, his corporate salary MOREOct 26, 2011 5:00 AM ET
|AT&T cuts prices again|
|Ukraine crisis: Aid, sanctions and fallout|
|Asian stocks slump after plane vanishes|
|Can Fox's reboot of 'Cosmos' find an audience?|
|Winners and losers of the bull market|