FORTUNE -- In August 2013, transgender television personality B. Scott filed a suit against Black Entertainment Television and its parent company Viacom Inc., claiming that the network had discriminated against him based on his gender identity and sexual orientation.
The lawsuit stemmed from Scott's appearance as a style correspondent at the 2013 BET awards preshow. After his first segment of the night, in which he appeared with heavy makeup and heels, the network told him to tone down his look and change into masculine clothing that was "different from the androgynous style he's used to ... and comfortable with," according to the complaint.
A Los Angeles Superior Court judge decided the case Wednesday, and it came down to the First Amendment; not Scott's freedom to speech and expression, but Viacom's (VIA). The court found that BET's decision as to how Scott would appear on camera was part of the network's creative process of developing and broadcasting the show, which is protected by the First Amendment.
The case is by no means the first in which a media company has used the First Amendment as a defense against lawsuits alleging discrimination. The order on Thursday cites several other instances.
There was the racial discrimination case against ABC for its failure to feature non-white contestants on The Bachelor and The Bachelorette. A federal district court in Tennessee dismissed the matter after finding that "casting decisions are a necessary component of any entertainment show's creative content." The court said that "the plaintiffs seek to drive an artificial wedge between casting decisions and the end product, which itself is indisputably protected as speech by the First Amendment."
And there was the lawsuit filed against Warner Bros. by a former writers' assistant for the television show Friends who asserted that the use of sexually coarse and vulgar language and conduct by the show's writers constituted sexual harassment. The Supreme Court of California in that case held that "the First Amendment protects creativity."
The case that held greatest precedent is a matter in which a group of gay, lesbian, and bisexual Irish Americans sought to participate in Boston's St. Patrick's Day parade. The U.S. Supreme Court, which ultimately heard the case, ruled that it would be a violation of the First Amendment for Massachusetts to require private citizens "who organize a parade to include among the marchers a group imparting a message the organizers do not wish to convey."
The defendants in these cases argued that they didn't care what their employees or participants are in reality -- gay, straight, male, female -- but rather how they appear. "They say, 'We are entitled to create a program that looks the way we want it to look,'" says Eugene Volokh, a professor at UCLA School of Law. And the courts have agreed with them.
Reporting the news and creating a television show both qualify as exercises of free speech, according to Thursday's ruling in the Scott case. Outside those realms, however, the First Amendment defense against discrimination claims doesn't work as well. Abercrombie & Fitch (ANF), for instance, lost a bias suit filed by a Muslim employee that it fired because she refused to remove her head scarf. Abercrombie had argued that any deviation from its dress code threatened the company's success and that the lawsuit violated its First Amendment right to commercial free speech. A federal judge in California disagreed.
"The First Amendment line is really drawn at news and entertainment," Volokh says. The Supreme Court has found that "people who make visual imagery are allowed to control what's in it."
Delaware law protects against board abuses by prescribing two well-known duties members owe to stockholders.
By Scott Kupor
FORTUNE -- Here's a catch-22: While someone starting a cosmetics company, for example, would prefer to surround themselves with the best and brightest in both industry domain expertise (someone who knows the cosmetics industry) and functional domain expertise (someone who knows direct-to-consumer marketing), they'd probably do exactly the opposite if their company were MOREApr 18, 2014 11:01 AM ET
A constant stream of interruptions all day long can make it hard to get much actual work done. But it's possible to take your time back.
FORTUNE -- Dear Annie: I work in an office that used to be a "cube farm," which was noisy and distracting enough, but now we've gone to an "open plan" layout where there are no walls at all between workstations. This is supposed to make collaboration MOREAnne Fisher, contributor - Apr 17, 2014 12:04 PM ET
Internships aren't jobs, so the same rules shouldn't apply.
By Sanjay Sanghoee
FORTUNE -- As we head from spring into summer, many college students are planning their vacations while those looking to get their first taste of the working world are likely hunting for internships.
It is estimated that U.S. companies hire about 1.5 million interns each year, half of them on an unpaid basis. Working for free might not be a MOREApr 17, 2014 10:45 AM ET
Eventually, every firm will discover that it's quite possible to manage without managers.
By Gary Hamel
(TheMIX) -- If you've spent a lifetime accumulating and wielding bureaucratic power, and if you've calibrated your career progress by the steps you've taken up the corporate ladder, or by the number of people who work for you, or the perks you've been awarded, or the scope of your authority, then envisioning a world in MOREApr 16, 2014 1:28 PM ET
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio signed into law a measure that will allow unpaid interns to file lawsuits against an employer for harassment and discrimination.
FORTUNE -- How much is justice worth? Unpaid interns planning to work in New York City this summer may want to crunch the numbers. They won't get a paycheck, but at least they now have the right to sue.
On Tuesday, Mayor Bill de Blasio signed MOREClaire Zillman, reporter - Apr 16, 2014 1:12 PM ET
People who get too little sleep are prone to go along with unethical practices at work, a study says -- unless they up their caffeine intake.
FORTUNE -- As if you needed another reason to run out for another cappuccino, along comes a new study by three university professors suggesting that caffeine may help make the sleep-deprived more honest.
"Our research shows that sleep deprivation contributes to unethical behavior at work by MOREAnne Fisher, contributor - Apr 16, 2014 11:47 AM ET
The law school recently cut its sticker price by 15%. Dean Nicholas Allard explains the school's rationale.
By Maya Itah
(TippingTheScales) -- When Brooklyn Law School announced earlier this month that it would cut tuition by 15%, it sounded less like a briefing and more like a battle cry.
"It's not just the 15% that we're reducing here," Brooklyn Law Dean Nicholas Allard says of the cut, which will go into effect MOREApr 15, 2014 10:56 AM ET
As companies compete on innovation and speed, decision-making comes less from executives at the top. Here are five ways to instill leadership across your organization.
By Deborah Ancona
FORTUNE -- Organizational change has never been easy, but in the past it was a little more straightforward. Fifty years ago, companies followed a basic blueprint. They had heroic leaders -- a CEO and an elite top layer of management -- who had MOREApr 15, 2014 10:44 AM ET
Many challenges at the office come down to managing our own personalities.
By John D. Mayer
FORTUNE -- Most of us would prefer to get through the workday without a scuffle. After all, very few of us are actively looking for a fight.
That said, getting along with our colleagues is no walk in the park, and this tension can influence our performance. Sometimes, an employee in our department is simply the MOREApr 14, 2014 12:57 PM ET
|GM's recalled Cobalt was a failure from the start|
|Why you should pay off your car loan ASAP|
|Americans have fallen in love with real estate once again|
|Pope Francis challenges the free market - The Buzz|
|Vladimir Putin called: He wants his warships|